Welcome or Register


My wife and I first went to the Butler area 4 years ago. The lake was our lure. We met Marty from a gentleman we rented a house from. If first impressions were indicative of our future interactions with Marty we would have to give six stars! Marty diligently worked with us for the next 4 years plowing through trials, tribulations, and many sad lost bids. I can not recall how many properties we researched together but Marty was always there for us with unparalleled enthusiasm, optimism, and positivity. After all this time and effort we finally purchased a home we fell in love with and Marty was there until the end. It was a bittersweet moment when we recognized that all the good times we had with Marty were now over. Several days after the sale I saw Marty coming up our (new) driveway. She approached me and told me that the sale was complete she was no longer our agent ... that she was now our good friend. This holds true to this day and we are still great friends with Marty. We consider ourselves blessed to have met her. Now we are looking for a parcel of land and we are right back in the mix. Trulia user96891318 (Buyer)
Marty has been the absolute best to work with! She has shown my husband several homes and been very patient with us! She is hard working, honest, dependable, and we love her to pieces. I would highly recommend her to anyone searching for a realtor. JJ Corby (Buyer)
My family had a superb experience with Marty while looking for and ultimately purchasing a second home in the Watauga Lake area. She lives in the area and seems to know everything that's going on. A lot of the other realtors in the area know her and respect her as well. Her local knowledge and connections were invaluable in helping us learn about the area, evaluate the various properties and areas we looked at, and ultimately to be 100% confident in the purchasing decision that we made. She won't try to sell you on every house you visit and she's not afraid to tell you about things to watch out for with specific houses. I really felt like Marty had our best interests at heart and wasn't simply looking for a quick sell. Throughout our (almost 5 month) looking and closing process Marty showed extreme patience and stood by us every step of the way. She was always super quick to return calls, followed up on the various bits of paperwork in a very timely fashion, and bent over backwards to accommodate our (mostly weekend) availability when looking at houses. Now that we've closed I can honestly say that Marty is not just our realtor, but someone that we're honored to count amongst our growing community of friends at Watauga Lake. I can recommend her services to anyone looking for real estate in the Watauga Lake area, without reservation. Trulia user3319019 (Buyer)
Marty was extremely helpful to me when I first became a real estate agent. She is very knowledgeable in all fields of the business and is very knowledgeable of this area. I am no longer in real estate and she was the first agent I thought about when I decided to list my home. She is currently my agent and I know that she will do everything in her power to do the job right. I highly recommend her for helping you sell your home or for helping you purchase your dream home. Cheryl Mills (Buyer)
We scheduled a trip to Tennessee for a short stay to look over potential homes or home sites. We had several properties we wanted to see, which Marty scheduled for us; then, on the basis of our discussions with her, she was able to take us to a number of other more interesting properties. She has just the right combination of local knowledge and professionalism to be invaluable home buyers in her area. We very much respect and appreciate her ability. John H.
If you are looking for a real estate agent that will get the job done for you that is Marty Plummer. We had our vacation home listed with another agent for close to three years, we gave the listing to Marty and she had it sold for us in a few short months! Marty lives in the area so she knows the area and the people. Her contacts are the best of the best. During our contract, Marty was in communication with us, answered all questions in a timely, professional manner, and ensured there were no bumps along the way to closing. This was one of the easiest closing we have had during our years of buying and selling real estate. There are other agents in the area and we have had dealings with some, and through it all, I would say “use Marty, you won't be sorry”. We will appreciate Marty and her experience for years to come. Trulia user4567060 (Seller)
Professional, personable, knowledgeable, responsive, Marty has been a pleasure to work with. She goes above and beyond to protect our interests and help us make the best decisions to met our needs. I would recommend her to anyone!! Trulia user750540
We highly recommend Marty for anyone looking to buy or sell property. She is honest, listens well, very knowledgeable, organized, and follows through on her commitments. Marty is the best Realtor we have ever worked with over the past 30 years. We initially had several homes that we asked Marty to show us that we found on Zillow. Marty listened carefully and observed our reactions to the properties to understand what we were looking for. The next time we went out with Marty, she showed us properties that were selected to meet our needs, and we found the perfect home for our family. Marty has been extremely helpful in the purchase this home, especially since we live over an hour away. Marty through a series of offers and counter offers successfully negotiated the price and terms of the purchase of our new home. Michael and Victoria Trulia user5554363 (Buyer)
Marty Plummer is an amazing Realtor! We have bought and sold 12 homes in the last 20 years, working with many agents and Marty far exceeds them all. She is the most honest, diligent and hardworking person you will come across. She is extremely knowledge about the Watauga Lake area, Butler and beyond. This lady can work with anyone; from first time buyers to multimillion dollar clients. She listens and responds. Marty has helped me with getting my house ready for the market and been a wealth of information. I have recommended her to several friends looking to buy or sell property and they were beyond satisfied. Whether you are looking for a home or land, call this expert. You will not be disappointed. Leeann Baker (Seller)
We have found Marty to be very patient and attentive as she works to meet the needs of her clients. We had very specific criteria that needed to be met to accommodate our goals in finding a home. We discovered that Marty was very professional, organized, responsive and not pushy. Marty is also very familiar with the area, its history and when asked for resource suggestions we discovered she was a great wealth of information. She was willing to take as many appointments as needed to find us the perfect location. Since our purchase, we have suggested her to many of our family and friends and they have found her to be delightful too. Kristen Watkins (Buyer)


Register Now

Already registered? Login

Sign in to take advantage of all this site has to offer. Save your favorite listings and searches – also receive email updates when listings you like come on the market for free!
*Contact Information is NOT Shared*

Quick Search

view all



No Min.

No Max.

Contact Us

* fields are required

Marty Plummer | Watauga Lake Real Estate | Phone: 423-768-3333 | martyp@centurylink.net
114 Piercetown Rd. Suite 101  Butler, TN 37640